One New Jersey Superior Court judge has decided that a child may decide whether to call a step-parent “Mom” or “Dad” or any derivative thereof. In a very lengthy decision in B.S. v. T.S., Ocean County Judge Lawrence Jones held that the 8 year-old boy involved is mature enough to make his own decision as to what he calls his father’s live-in girlfriend, contrary to the position of the biological Mother.
Upheaval of Divorce and Grant of Power to Child
The court determined that the child’s parents’ divorce had caused enough upheaval in his life, over which he had no control whatsoever. Therefore, the court gives the child control over what he decides to call his Dad’s live-in girlfriend. The Father is engaged to the live-in girlfriend with whom the child has a very positive relationship, the trauma suffered by the child throughout the divorce and subsequent court involvement concerning the child, the fact that the girlfriend’s three children living in the boy’s household and the girlfriend’s past teaching experience all seem to come into play in the Court’s granting the child the power to make his own decision as to what to call this woman. There is no way to tell if any or all of these factors will play a part in future determinations on the issue.
The impression provided by this decision is that the parents are and were too often in court, unable to work out things without on their own. The child may well have been put him in the middle of it all. This parental behavior may well have played a role in the final determination by the court. The court made clear the positive nature of the relationship between the child, both parents and the girlfriend, expressed by the child, avoiding any impression that this decision was based upon anything lacking in the biological mother. Continue Reading →